Tim - that's a tough question, and a pretty darn interesting one at that.
The other way to look at it, in the winter it tends to be cloudy more frequently and your car might be covered with snow - the solar heat gained by the black might not pan out very often.
It is true that the heater uses more energy than the air conditioning. A black car is going to be a lot hotter in the summer than a white or silver car. So the air conditioner might have to work really hard in the summer with the black car.
There is a movement to make roofs of buildings white for energy efficency. I'd follow that cue myself.
On the other hand, that tuxedo black is darn pretty. And so is the platiumn white and ingot silver.